Page 39 - 臺灣原住民族法學期刊第一卷第八期

༨਷ঐ๕ҳ༟e͑ᚃ೯࢝ၾࡡИ͏ɛᛆj˸ڐϋ਷ყʮߒ೯࢝ၾൡதࣩԷމࣨː

И͏ૄɛᛆʘ຾ՊࣩԷeڐϋอጳʘ༨ਜਹ˸ʿऒʿʔΝن၌ஈଣዚՓࣩԷd੽ԫ
ʱؓၾˢ༰ʈЪf͟׵޴ᗫࣩԷ଺εd͉˖̙ঐೌجνɓছٟึ߅ኪ޼ӺආБᅵ͉

פᅵၾࣩԷ፯՟f್͉˖ࣩԷ፯՟ٙᅺ๟˴ࠅϞɧj(1) ˸ͩʷঐ๕ҳ༟ჯਹމ˴
ʘൡதࣩ€ΪՉஷ੬ிϓ༰ɽʘᐑྤၾɛᛆฦ࢔i(2) ҎૐΝࣛ੻ࡒᚥཀֻ຾Պe

Ϟ˾ڌ׌ʘࣩԷ€νଘऒɽඎʘա࢔ɛe਷ყద᜗ᗫءʘ༨਷હ᏶ཀ೻eൡத೻ҏ
ঃࣛ஢ɮnഃd˸ʿڐϋอጳʘൡதن၌dЪމ࿁ˢi(3) ௰ܝɰਿ׵༟ࣘʘ̙

੻׌dΪ஢ε਷ყҳ༟΀൒ʘʫ࢙Ԩ͊࿁̮౧ᚣʮකfୋʞ௅ʱdਗ਼ఱה፯ࣩԷя
ତʘنᓃeऒʿʘ஝ᇍቇ͜ၾطଣዚՓdމආɓӉʘၝΥᝈ࿀ၾ൙ؓdԨ౤̈͊Ը

޼Ӻ˙Σf௰ܝۆ݊ഐႧdৰ࿜ࠅΌ˖̮dԨఱϤᗳࣩ΁࿁׵ၽᝄجՓၾ਷ყஹഐ
ʘ̙ঐ઼೯d౤̈ڋӉᝈ࿀f

൩e຾᏶Όଢʷe༟๕ચྮၾࡡИ͏ૄʘᛆлҤن

੽ɤɖ˰ߏක֐dΌଢ΢ήٙࡡИ͏ૄdఱ਺ܵίՉෂ୕ɺήၾ࢕෤ɪdתҤ
8
ԸІᆄݲٙୋɓتಟ͏˴່ fڐϋһ͟׵Όଢ༟͉˴່ጳৎeబ༃਷࢕ɛ͏ऊ൬ۨ
࿒ᔷᜊd˸ʿ΢਷࿁І್༟๕ʘცӋ౤৷dอɓتٙ༨਷຾᏶ݺਗၾ༟͉ɰݴආə
9
อٙήଣ٤ගdவʕගɰܼ̍Ⴣᕎே̹ٙࡡИ͏ૄෂ୕ჯਹ f
ՉʕdГ˙˖׼਷࢕࿁׵І್༟๕{Էν˝ҿeᘤପe༵ପۜeͩذnഃʘಸ

ӋdᒈԴ༨਷Άุٙᐄ༶dʔᓙۃֻϤᗳ༟๕ᘾᔛᔮబʘਜਹdνjזɕߕݲeڢ
ݲၾ؇یԭഃήfՉʕd஢εࡡИ͏ૄෂ୕ჯਹdɰᘾᔛᔮӒʘІ್༟๕dΪϾɰ
10
ϓމГ˙༨਷Άุᕁ֛ʘͦᅺ fΎ̋ɪዝ຾ɚϣ˰ޢɽ኷ܝd਷ყɪίശସ཭΍
ᗆ€Washington ConsensusၾอІ͟˴່຾᏶ኪ€neo-liberal economicsٙܠᆓ
ၾ݁ഄ˴ኬɨd਷ყ೯࢝ዚ࿴€νj˰ޢვБe਷ყ஬࿆ਿږഃה˴ኬੂБʘ஢

εක೯ࠇ೥d࿁׵ΌଢࡡИ͏ૄ፠˸މ͛ʘɺήeෂ୕͛ݺe˖ʷႩΝnഃdேପ
11
͛ࠠɽʘࠋࠦᅂᚤ f

8cAlfred, T., & Corntassel, J. (2005). Being Indigenous: Resurgences against contemporary
colonialism. Government and opposition, 40(4), 597-614. ʕ˖˖ᘠሗԈ : ቍၪʕ . (1992). ൙
ʧੰ੃ᅃഹ ಟ͏ซ྅ၾή˙ݴᜊ : ஃᚆ؇Ιܓʮ̡ၾၽᝄࡡИ͏‘Planning, 10, 23-40.
9c Harvey, D. (2016). Neoliberalism is a political project. Jacobin magazine. Fenelon, J.
V., & Hall, T. D. (2008). Revitalization and indigenous resistance to globalization and
neoliberalism. American Behavioral Scientist, 51(12), 1867-1901.
10c Ojha, H. R., Ford, R., Keenan, R. J., Race, D., Vega, D. C., Baral, H., & Sapkota, P. (2016).
Delocalizing communities: Changing forms of community engagement in natural resources
governance. World Development, 87, 274-290. ݄͍ቜ , & юभ຃ . (2008). ࡡИ͏ૄၾІ್
༟๕ٙ΍၍ . Taiwan Journal of Indigenous Studies, 1(1), 1-38.
11c Sarfaty, G. A. (2004). The World Bank and the internalization of indigenous rights norms.
Yale LJ, 114, 1791.

37