Page 59 - 臺灣原住民族法學期刊第一卷第八期

༨਷ঐ๕ҳ༟e͑ᚃ೯࢝ၾࡡИ͏ɛᛆj˸ڐϋ਷ყʮߒ೯࢝ၾൡதࣩԷމࣨː

ʘஃᚆج৫dޫމ༈ࣩࡡѓరӋહ᏶ʘ၍༸f

ఱࣩ΁ஈଣࣛࣖ˸ᝈd˸ɪࣩԷѩяତdϤᗳ༨਷͏ԫӋᎵၾࡡИ͏ૄɛᛆڧ
࢔ࣩ΁d׵ሜݟၾᄲଣཀ೻ਗ਼඲ঃࣛޟɮfуԴᐏ੻௷ൡאձ༆d௰୞הᐏʘሦᎵ

אձ༆ږᕘdɰჃЭ׵Չฦ࢔dϾසՈ൥ᅄจ່f್Ͼd࿁׵రӋહ᏶ʘࡡИ͏ૄ
ၾՉ˾ଣܛࢪϾԊdவԬሦᎵא஢͉࣬ʔԑ˸ఎΫʊ஻٫ʘ͛նfШൡதʘഐ؈d
̙Σಠ೐e௛НᎲഃ׵ක೯ʕ਷࢕ᐄ༶ٙ༨਷ͩذ̶᎘ෂ༺ɓධৃࢹjʔঐਗ਼ڧ͕

ɛᛆ຅ϓ຾ᐄ͛จٙ˓ݬאࠠࠅ௅ʱfϾߕ਷ج৫ᗫ׵༺߅෫፩ذ၍ʘᐑ൙ൡதd
ۆ݊ீཀ਷ʫج৫હ᏶dᐏ੻ϓ̌ၾཫԣ̌ࣖʘԷf͊ԸνОீཀһεᐑ൙ൡதd

˸ཫԣࡡИ͏ɛᛆቊաڧ࢔dᏐމࠠࠅʘൡதഄଫၾᒈැf

ఱ਷ყહ᏶ᄴϣd͉˖፯՟ʘࣩԷdೌجяତהϞ਷ყહ᏶၍༸אɛᛆ္છዚ
Փʘ༶Ъ̌ࣖf್ڋӉᝈ࿀d׵ෂ୕਷ყਠਕʘنதၾહ᏶၍༸dνj͏ԫൡதe

਷ყਠਕאҳ༟΀൒ഃdίϤԬહ᏶ዚՓʕሔሞɛᛆᙄᕚdהᐏʘഐ؈ʔɓf዆ଣ
ϾԊd׵਷ყਠਕ΀൒אҳ༟΀൒ዚՓஈଣɛᛆᙄᕚdא΀൒٫౪ˏe༶͜਷ყɛ
57
ᛆجʘઋҖdʊ൳Ԉ౷ཁ fϤ̮dίڐಂʘˋГࣩԷʕd਷ყΑԫج৫ɰක֐ו
ዄಂܙdҎૐঐ࿁׵ࠠɽʘᐑྤ͕ໆe͛࿒ၾ၇ૄ๘ഒБމdҲစᗫᒟԉЍfΪϤd
਷ყΑԫج৫࿁׵ࠠɽʘࡡИ͏ૄɛᛆڧ࢔ၾ͛࿒ॎᕸࣩ΁dঐ೯౨εˇൡ৛ၾӺ
58
ப̌ঐdɰ࠽੻ܵᚃᗫء͉ࣩܝᚃ f
͉˖Ⴉމd࿁׵΢၇હ᏶၍༸dνj਷ʫج৫e਷ყ΀൒eɛᛆਖ਼பዚ࿴ʘહ

᏶ዚՓഃdՉ΢Іʘ༶Ъྼࣖd͊ԸᏐܵᚃމྼᗇ൙Пၾሜݟˢ༰dԨ΢હ᏶Փܓ
ගʘ዆Υၾҷࠧ౤̈஝ྌܠϽf

ఱၽᝄʫ਷ൡதၾ਷ყɛᛆʘஹഐϾԊdҢ਷Ԩ͊ᖦ໇ɪකᑌΥ਷ࡡИ͏ૄ޴

ᗫʘ਷ყʮߒf್І 2009 ϋ˸Ըdၽᝄִ݁ጐ฽પਗ˸˜ʮߒ݄Бجᅼό™ҁϓ
əܼ̍ʮ͏ၾ݁طᛆл਷ყʮߒ‘ʿ຾᏶ٟึ˖ʷᛆл਷ყʮߒ‘ഃʬɽࠠࠅ

਷ყʮߒٙ਷ʫجʷࠠࠅʈ೻fϤ၇ᅼόЪجᐏ੻਷ყᄿعٵ֛dΪਗ਼਷ყج஝᜗
ӻˏɝdਗ਼Ң਷جطʿ̡جྼਕʘɛᛆڭღଉϞڮආfՉʕd຅್ɰ̍ў͉˖ۃࠑ
ၾࡡИ͏ૄɛᛆ޴ᗫ௅ʱf

࠯΋dఱɓࡈࡡИ͏ૄɛᛆ̡جࡈࣩԊdҢ਷ج৫˜Ꮠщቇ͜Շʮߒ™k࿁Ϥ

ࠠࠅᙄᕚdҢ਷ኪ٫࿋၅त઺બ೯ڌ׵ၽᝄɛᛆኪ̊ୋɓಂʘ҃˖d˸ʿՉɓӻΐ

57c Simma, B. (2011). Foreign Investment arbitration: a place for human rights?. International
and Comparative Law Quarterly, 573-596. Steininger, S. (2018). What's Human Rights
Got To Do With It? An Empirical Analysis of Human Rights References in Investment
Arbitration. Leiden Journal of International Law, 31(1), 33-58.
58c White, R. (Ed.). (2017). Transnational environmental crime. Routledge. Sharp, P. (1999).
Prospects for environmental liability in the International Crimi nal Court. Virginia
Environmental Law Journal, 217-243. ௓ٔ . (2018). ሞ਷ყΑԫج৫ίᐑྤڭᚐʕٙᔖঐ
( ʕ਷݁جɽኪ၂ɻሞ˖ ).

57