Page 30 - 臺灣原住民族法學期刊第一卷第一期
P. 30

28  ၽᝄࡡИ͏ૄجኪg2016 ϋ 7 ˜gୋ 1 ՜ୋ 1 ಂ




               ಂ஢œࡡඊၾִ݁ዚᗫਗ਼ʔΎ೯͛ላ߉i৷ږ९                          ක஭ᓪࣩ΁ࣛdһ੽˜ࡡИ͏ૄၾ̨ᝄִ݁อٙ
               ૠڌͪjʊִֻ݁࿁׵ࡡИ͏dœৰəኮجٙڭ                           ྫМᗫڷ™՘֛d˸ʿ˜ᑌΥ਷ࡡИ͏ૄᛆл܁
               ღ̮d੽ԸӚϞɓ௅جܛ݊ڭღࡡИ͏ૄdϤܝ                           Ԋ™ٙᝈᓃ̈೯dᙕࠑБމɛʔՈ௪˴ᝈ͕ໆࠅ
               ຅ʚѓйiಀശᅃ։ࡰ౑၈jœࡡИ͏εϋԸேί                          ΁f̙Ԉί޴ᗫجܛӚϞࡌࠈٙઋҖɨdҢ਷̡
               రӋዝ̦ٙ˴᜗׌dҢࡁ੬ชྖjࡡИ͏ʔ݊ʔ                           جዚᗫڐϋԸ࿁ࡡИ͏הऒʿΑԫ͕ໆࣛdʊঐ
               ςجdϾ݊ੂִ݁ٙ݁ʔഗج΢ഃႧf༐۔౶                           ੽εʩ˖ʷٙᝈᓃdᙕࠑೌໆкӔʘଣ͟d຅᙮
               ԊlၲʘːაfତБΑԫൡதجୋɧɤɓૢୋɓ                           ̡جᛆʘІҢ޲ܠf
               ධୋ̬ಛԨᄣΐ஗ѓՈࡡИ͏Ԓʱd຾Աஷ੬೻                               ࡡИ͏ࡈɛऒʿ͕ໆࣛd̡جዚᗫᒱʊ౪ˏ
               ҏৎൡאᄲк٫d͊຾፯΂ᚗᚐɛࣛdᏐܸ֛ᚗ                           ਷ყɛᛆڭღ˸ʿεʩ˖ʷٙᝈᓃdШϤၾٵႩ
               ᚐɛމՉᚗᚐiୋʞධ஝֛d׵ਈݟʕ͊຾፯΂                           ࡡИ͏ૄණ᜗ᛆл€νෂ୕ჯਹdʥϞʔΝf
               ᚗᚐɛ٫dᏨ࿀֜e̡جᙆ࿀֜א̡جᙆ࿀Ꮠஷ                           ౬Ԋʘdࡡ͏ࡈɛऒʿ͕ໆࣛd̡جዚᗫνОᄲ
               ٝԱجணͭʘجܛҧпዚ࿴ܸݼܛࢪՑఙމՉᚗ                           ଣʿкӔdසऒʿࡡИ͏ࡈɛdϾΫూࡡИ͏ૄ
               ᚐfɦІୋɚϣ˰ޢɽ኷˸ܝdΑԫྼ᜗جආӉ                           ෂ୕ჯਹdࠠอܔ࿴ૄ໊ၾɺήٙᗫڷdۆʥϞ
               ଣׂdʊ͟ෂ୕ٙ਷࢕˴່ᄆ࠽ᝈdᔷΣࡈɛ˴                           ܙ̡جᛆһආɓӉীሞe޲ܠf˸ෂ୕ჯਹʘن
               ່ᄆ࠽ᝈdኪଣɪ၈މΑجᑹҵܠซdႩމΑԫ                           ᙄމԷdί̡ج೻ҏɪdΫూࡡИ͏ૄ࿁׵ɺή
               ၮ݊௰ܝٙ˓ݬdνԱ͏جאБ݁جdʊ̙༺Ց                           ʘණ᜗ᛆлdՉѢᗭ೻ܓჃ৷׵࿁ࡡИ͏ࡈɛ݊
               ၪٟܵึ່͍ٙЪ͜dࡡۆɪఱೌ˸Αၮ޴̋ʘ                           щ͕ໆٙᄲଣfՉࡡΪί׵਷࢕جܛ޶ܙɺήٙ
               ̀ࠅfϤ׵౷ஷΑجeतйΑجiჀໆeࠠໆʘ                           ᝈᓃdၾࡡИ͏ૄ࿁׵ɺήٙႩٝdϞഹ͉ሯɪ
                                                                     52
               ໾̂ᗫڷd׵ͭج൒ඎҨ኿ࣛdΝᏐϽඎi׵̡                           ٙࢨମ f͡Ԋʘdਿ׵༟͉˴່הணࠇٙ਷࢕ج
               جྼਕቇ͜ɪdۆ඲ܮΑf஭ϮطໆૢԷୋ̬ૢ                           ܛdႩމɺή݊ɓ၇˜ਠۜ™€commoditydɺή
               ୋɓධୋɓಛʘڧ̕ʮϞৌيໆdج˖ʘʫdᒱ                           הঐପ͛ʘ఩ࢹd຅್̀඲ўܼίʫd˲ѩ᙮̹
               ್͊༱׼ʔجהϞʘ˴ᝈ͕จࠅ΁dШ݅ڷΑج                           ఙʹ׸ٙᅺٙfШ݊dࡡИ͏Ⴉމɺή̳݊ԃૄ
               ୋɧϵɧɤʬૢୋɓධʮਕڧ̕ໆʘतйجd݂                           ໊͛նٙ༟๕€resourcedϤධ༟๕νΝ٤ंe
               Չ࿴ϓdΝᏐՈϞϤ˴ᝈ͕จdɗجଣה຅್f                           ऎݱɓছdʔ̙ঐ᙮׵त֛ࡈɛהϞϾϓމɓ၇
               ࡊБމɛᆽϞΪʮ˕͜e͊ໝɝӷᚾdІʔঐ                            ਠۜdޟЇආБ൯ርd੽௅ໝ˖ʷٙᝈᓃϾԊd
               ႩՉπϞʔجڧ̕ʘ͕จdᐽ್Չజ੮ኯᗇʔᄁ                           л͜ɺή༟๕ٙᛆлd݊᙮׵Ό᜗ૄ໊הϞϾڢ
               Όdא˸ʔྼఊኽ૿̂dʥೌ஽˸ɪ౧஭ϮໆΤ                           ࡈɛf̙Ԉί਷࢕جՓɨdӷɛ࿁׵त֛ɺήʊ
               ޴ᖬʘቱήdࠅʘd߂᙮৽ி˖ࣣໆ௝ʘᇍᖚf                           ኹϞجܛהረʚٙᛆлdШࡡИ͏ૄ࿁׵ෂ୕ჯ
               Չྼdึࠇኯᗇᗳεeۨᕏeᅰᐿdజ੮݅ࠅӋ                           ਹۆϞՉ˖ʷዝ̦ɪٙ၍ჯᛆdՇ٫ʘගνОሜ
                                                                            53
               ജྼe̶୚ᗰ፲dԫઋІ್Їމိຟdৰڢڷึ                           ዆dྼ᙮ʔ׸ fΪϤdνОீཀ̡جዚᗫٙ౽
               ࠇeᐼਕɛࡰdΪ᙮Չਖ਼ุჯਹdபೌࣙ൲d                            ᅆdί־Ϥٙ˖ʷࢨମʕdҬ̈௰ቇ֝ٙ༆Ӕ˙
                                                                                   54
               Ш׵Չ˼ɓছࡒ፬ʘɛϾԊd೵ಂɓeɚ˚dא                           όdʥϞܙһεٙীሞ f࠽੻̡جᛆ޲ܠٙ݊d
               ஢೓ঐ௷΂dڗಂபϓd৉ఘࠋஃfɓছɛ͏ν                           ί޴ᗫجܛӚϞࡌࠈٙઋҖɨd̋ࣅɽ௰৷ج৫
               Ϥd઺ԃ˥̻֠ܙᄣආʘࡡИ͏ू݊f̚Ԋjʔ઺                          ٵႩӻنɺή᙮Tsilhqot’inʘෂ୕ჯਹdᏐ̙Ъ
               Ͼ༒dፗʘ߿iνʦִ߰݁࿁׵ʔՈϞึࠇజ੮                           މҢ਷̡جዚᗫί͊ԸᄲଣࡡИ͏ૄණ᜗ᛆлن
               ਖ਼ุʘࡡИ͏d٨ᚥՉίʆਜ՟ኽѢᗭdޟЇ࣬                           ᙄࣛٙ࠾ᗝl
               ͉ೌ੽՟ኽʘତྼ೾رdසଫ݄ᅰʃࣛʘᑺ୦d
               уࠅӋʕ஝ʕॉdщۆՉೌجࣨቖʘʮಛ௅ʱd                           52   Էνjίದىٟึʔცࠅ࿁ɺήҳɝ௶ਗၾ༟͉d
               ̀Ա஭Ϯڧࠠ̕ໆሞᏝdՉ༼່ḛ຅eʔ֝d                             Ш݊࿁׵ίದىήᓃཱቮٙ࢕ळdۆ̀඲ҳɝ௶ਗ
                                                                 ၾ༟͉dۆ࿁ದى͏ૄϾԊdᛆлٙᝈׂึ̈ତί
                                                       51
               ೌܙεԊf̡ج֜৛Ӌࡈ່ࣩ͍dʪ֝ଉܠf ™                            ࢕ळϾڢɺήfϤၾ༟͉˴່ٟึਗ਼ɺήٟމࠠࠅ
                   ͟ϤᝈʘdҢ਷ج৫׵ᄲଣ㋖˝ࣩࣛႩމd                           ᛆл܄᜗ٙܠϽ˙όd࿚್ʔΝfሗਞԈj̋ᖸඩ
                                                                 ڦഹdቍٻႂᙇ€2012dהϞᛆٙሖ͛‘dࠫ
               ν؈਷࢕͊ঐՓ֛޴஝֛dࡡИ͏̙˸ԱኽՉ˖                             68-69d̏ԯjجܛ̈وٟf
               ʷ࿕୦dίෂ୕ჯਹમණ؍˝༟๕fϾίᄲଣɪ                           53   See also Dwight G. Newman & Danielle Schweitzer,
                                                                 Between Reconciliation and The Rule(s) of Law: Tsilh-
                                                                 qot’in Nation v. British Columbia, 41 U.B.C. L. REV.
               51   ௰৷ج৫ 103 ϋܓ̨ɪοୋ 900 ໮ΑԫкӔd̡                  249, 259-63 (2008).
                 ج৫جኪ༟ࣘᏨ॰ӻ୕jhttp://jirs.judicial.gov.tw/       54  Jarboe, supra note25, at 401-02. Mezey, supra note 48,
                 FJUD/index.htmf                                 at 57-8.
   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35